Lawrence County officials plead with commissioners to reconsider county health insurance amid rising costs and staff departures

BEDFORD — Lawrence County Clerk Amy Voorhies and Sheriff Greg Day both voiced frustrations to the Lawrence County Board of Commissioners, urging officials to seek an alternative health insurance policy for county employees as rising out-of-pocket costs are straining workers and causing staff turnover.

Lawrence County Clerk Amy Voorhies

During the meeting, Voorhies stressed that the county’s recent transition to a new insurance model is driving employees away. She told the commissioners she has already lost one staff member and has another actively searching for a new job due to the increased financial burden of the coverage.

“I strongly urge you to find another option,” Voorhies said. “The rates with this insurance have increased huge amounts on prescriptions and doubled for emergency room visits.”

Sheriff Greg Day

Sheriff Greg Day echoed those concerns, sharing the personal financial impact the policy change has had on his own coverage. Day noted that his insurance costs have increased by more than $100, and he now faces $4,000 in out-of-pocket expenses.

Sheriff Greg Day reported that while he has successfully filled three dispatch positions—with two currently in training and the third set to begin in a few weeks—his department is still actively seeking to fill three deputy vacancies and one courthouse security spot. However, Day stressed that retention remains a major hurdle, noting that he is losing employees just as quickly as he hires them due to better opportunities elsewhere.

Background on the County Insurance Restructuring

The officials’ latest pushback comes on the heels of a major restructuring of the county employee health insurance program. Commissioners previously approved the overhaul in response to staggering premium increases that threatened to double costs under the county’s former carrier.

During a special meeting, the Board of Commissioners voted to transition county staff to an Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement (ICHRA) managed through J.W. Fansler and J&J Benefits. Commissioners noted they were forced to seek alternative options when traditional group coverage became financially unsustainable.

Under the ICHRA framework, the county subsidizes employee premiums while allowing workers to select individual coverage options through a broader federal marketplace network.

Key Features of the ICHRA Structure:

  • Baseline Plan: PPO structure with a $1,500 deductible
  • Network Scope: Expanded provider network compared to the former Anthem plan
  • Eligibility: Guaranteed coverage with no pre-existing condition exclusions
  • Spousal Rule: Mandatory carve-out if a spouse has access to employer coverage
  • Medicare Transition: Medicare-eligible staff must use Medicare as primary coverage

At the time of the approval, officials highlighted that pooling claims into a broader market risk pool would prevent individual high-cost claims from triggering massive, localized rate hikes across the county’s small employment group. While payroll contributions were projected to remain flat or slightly decrease for most workers, the transition has sparked ongoing pushback regarding out-of-pocket expenses, administrative hurdles, and potential gaps in secondary coverage like dental and vision.

Ongoing Pushback from Department Heads

Voorhies has consistently characterized the ICHRA transition as a temporary fix rather than a permanent solution. In previous remarks to the board on behalf of her staff, she acknowledged the time crunch commissioners faced when finding a replacement plan, while criticizing the income-based pricing structure of the marketplace model.

“We understand the commissioners were crunched for time to find a new insurance option — you did, Obamacare. Not sure that counts, but you did,” Voorhies said previously, comparing the system to buying a watermelon at a grocery store without a price tag until presenting a pay stub at the register.

While county staff worked to find affordable plans under the new framework, the latest updates from both Voorhies and Day underscore that sharp spikes in premiums, deductibles, prescriptions, and emergency room costs are heavily impacting county personnel and retention.