Bedford Man Arrested On Home Improvement Fraud

(BEDFORD) – A Bedford man was arrested after a traffic stop on a warrant charging him with theft, home improvement fraud and being a habitual traffic offender.

Bruce Sims

Lawrence County Sheriff’s Department officers arrested 47-year-old Bruce Sims, of 1403 Oak Manor.

According to a probable cause affidavit, on July 17, 2019, a woman reported home improvement fraud.

The woman stated she contacted Affordable Kitchens 2 U at 2832 Washington Avenue about doing some work on her bathroom and kitchen.

The woman told police she spoke to the owner Lucille Birch about completing some work in her bathroom which included removing and replacing a vanity, bathtub, and toilet. She also wanted the cabinets, countertop, and sink removed and replaced in her kitchen.

Birch told the woman it might take up to five weeks before they could get started on the work.

A week later, Sims, who is Birch’s fiance, went to the woman’s home and took some measurements.

The owner of the home did not hear from either Birch or Sims for a couple of weeks. On October 18, 2019 she went to their office to see what was taking so long.

The homeowner spoke with Birch and was given an invoice for the work to be done.

The homeowner paid Birch $7,200 as a down payment per Birch’s request to get the work started.

The homeowner was given two invoices; one for the bathroom and one for the kitchen.

After paying the money, the homeowner told police she did not hear back from either Birch or Sims until the end of February 2020 when she contacted them. The woman told police the two never contacted her and she always had to be the one to contact them. The homeowner told police that during the time prior to February 2020, Birch always had excuse after excuse as to why the work was delayed.

Sims finally arrived with an assistant to work at the homeowner’s house in February 2020. The homeowner stated that they tore out the existing bathtub and vanity and replaced only the bathtub.

The homeowner told police Sims did the plumbing incorrectly and it leaked.

Since that day no one has been back to the home or returned the homeowner’s money.

The homeowner contacted Birch numerous times and they will not return her calls.

The homeowner then hired David Smith of McIntyre & Smith Law Firm for legal assistance. Attorney Dave Smith sent Affordable Kitchen two letters and received no reply from either.

On May 16, 2020 the homeowner was finally able to contact Birch on Facebook and request a refund.

Birch asked why the homeowner didn’t want the job completed. Birch told the woman she planned on finishing the work and had purchased the cabinets and they would arrive by the middle of June or possibly sooner.

Birch told the homeowner she was having problems with suppliers due to COVID-19. She then told the homeowner one of the supply trucks carrying the homeowner’s cabinets had been in a wreck and she was working with the insurance company to replace the damaged cabinets.

On July 31, 2020, police attempted to contact Birch, but there was no one in the office and a sign on the door said no one will be working at the business for a while.

On August 19, 2020, police contacted the homeowner and she had not heard or received a refund from Sims or Birch.

On September 4, 2020, police contacted Birch who told the detective the situation was difficult because the cabinets were ordered from overseas. Birch told the detective they have not given a refund to the homeowner and have completed probably $5,000 in work.

The detective told Birch he had been in the homeowner’s house and $5,000 worth of work had not been completed and what work was done was not done correctly.

After speaking with the detective, Birch told police she would contact the homeowner and she would be willing to work out something regarding refunds and repayments.

After a few days had passed, the detective called the homeowner who said she has had no contact with Birch or Sims.

The information was forward to the Prosecutor’s Officer requesting arrest warrants on both Sims and Birch.