Teased, but not pleased, BNL falls a shot short during 58-55 road loss at South

BLOOMINGTON – BNL’s Sammie Nusbaum finds a gap in Bloomington South’s defense. Nusbaum scored 22 points, but the Panthers escaped with a 58-55 win on Tuesday night.

By Justin Sokeland

WBIW.com

BEDFORD – Victory was a flirting tease. Each time Bedford North Lawrence was enticed, promised a shot at an early-season defining moment, that chance was ripped away. BNL now understands how Charlie Brown felt when Lucy yanked the football back before he could kick it.

Bloomington South played the heartbreaker. The Panthers allowed the Stars to get close, only to prick BNL’s momentum ballon with 3-point pins. While the Stars were great on approach, South finished each quarter with dagger shots that burst on impact. BNL was left holding the corsage, rather than going home with a huge win.

Every scene played out the same as South slipped away with a 58-55 triumph on Tuesday night. Kate Lehr, a transfer from Bloomington North who was first destined for BNL at one point in the summer move, scored 17 points as the Panthers (3-1) won their third straight in the series.

This one hurt a little more. BNL (2-2) was in position for a monumental road win, only for South to change the direction – and ultimately the outcome – with key closing minutes in each quarter. The Panthers finished the first with 10 straight points, scored nine points in less than a minute to flip the first half, erupted for nine consecutive points after BNL grabbed its last lead late in the third, then held off BNL’s late charge with six free throws during the last 90 seconds.

“At the end of the quarters, we’re pretty good,” South coach Larry Winters said. “That shows we have the capability to do it. We just wait until the hands are around our neck to relax and play.”

South did most of its damage from long range, especially at the conclusion of the middle quarters. BNL had just erased a 10-point deficit with its best run, roaring to a 26-22 advantage near the end of the half. Then boom, boom, boom . . . sonic blasts from Addy Prall, Annika Smith and Tatum DeVries powered South to a 31-26 halftime lead. After BNL’s Sammie Nusbaum scored from close range for a 38-37 lead late in the third, South exploded again. Treys from DeVries and Lehr ended the quarter, and Smith started the fourth with another for a 46-38 edge.

Finally, after Nusbaum swished a bomb from in front of the BNL bench, powering the Stars within 53-51 with 54.5 seconds left, South made clutch free throws to keep the Stars at bay.

“We were right there,” BNL coach Chase Spreen said. “We needed one more to go down, one more stop. That’s tough to swallow right now.”

BNL was very good for many minutes. Miley Sherrill crashed the wing for a layup, Nusbaum scored off a Jordynn Blann steal, Elahdy Ray popped a 10-footer in the lane, and Sherrill stroked a 15-footer for the 26-22 lead. Nusbaum scored three times as BNL erased the halftime deficit. Sherrill drove to a 3-point play that cut South’s lead to 46-43. But the next South possession was four points – an Avery Swartzman drive for a basket and foul, followed by a third-shot score off the missed free throw for a 50-43 lead that was just took much to overcome.

BLOOMINGTON – BNL’s Miley Sherrill works inside against South’s Kate Lehr. Sherrill scored 13 points.

“We have to figure out a way to fight through that and finish possessions,” Spreen said. “We have to be able to run those down. We battled, we just came up a little bit short.”

Nusbaum finished with 22 points, Sherrill totaled 13, and Caroline Sheldon added 8 with two treys. BNL hit eight from distance, had only three turnovers in the second half (after 10 in the first), won the rebounding stat (with Blann grabbing 8), and shot 52.5 percent (21 of 40). And that was not quite good enough.

“It always gets me, when I watch BNL play and then watch them play against me, they don’t miss shots,” Winters said. “They shot lights out. It’s just amazing. I guess I bring it out in people. They stay in their stuff, they won’t deviate from what they do, and they’re very good at it. They ran their stuff and picked us apart.”

Smith totaled 16 points for South, which hit 10 treys (the bulk of its 17 field goals). Quinn Wurtzman, a freshman who looks and plays older, had 9 points off the bench.

“If the lid comes off for us, we’re going to be really good,” Winters said. “We have some really good shooters. Right now, they’re getting a little frustrated with themselves, so we have to get the mental part straightened out. When that happens, you’re going to see a pretty good team.”

“They hit lot of timely ones,” Spreen said. “It seemed like every time we took the lead, they hit one the next possession. That’s just kids stepping up to make plays.”

BNL will host Seymour in its Hoosier Hills Conference opener on Saturday.

BLOOMINGTON – BNL’s Caroline Sheldon scores from close range. Sheldon totaled 8 points.

BEDFORD NL STARS (55)

3s FGs FTs R F Pts

23 Sammie Nusbaum, f 4-6 9-16 0-0 7 4 22

22 Miley Sherrill, f 0-2 5-9 3-3 1 2 13

21 Jordynn Blann, g 2-4 2-4 0-0 8 3 6

12 Elahdy Ray, g 0-2 1-4 1-2 3 3 3

24 Caroline Sheldon, g 2-4 3-5 0-0 1 3 8

31 Audrey Hoffman 0-0 1-2 1-2 1 2 3

Totals 8-18 21-40 5-7 24 17 55

BLOOMINGTON SOUTH PANTHERS (58)

3s FGs FTs R F Pts

2 Tatum DeVries, f 2-6 2-7 0-0 5 1 6

4 Amaya Stinson, f 0-0 0-0 1-2 2 0 1

21 Kate Lehr, g 2-5 5-10 5-7 3 1 17

10 Annika Smith, g 3-5 4-10 5-6 4 1 16

5 Avery Swartzman, g 1-3 2-6 1-3 2 3 6

22 Quinn Wurtzman 1-2 3-5 2-2 2 2 9

1 Addy Prall 1-2 1-2 0-0 3 0 3

Totals 10-23 17-41 14-20 20 8 58

Bedford NL 7 19 12 17 – 55

Bl. South 14 17 12 15 – 58

Turnovers – BNL 13, South 8

Field goal percentage – BNL 21-40 (.525); South 17-41 (.415)

Free throw percentage – BNL 5-7 (.714); South 14-20 (.700)

BLOOMINGTON – BNL’s Elahdy Ray attempts to drive past South’s Tatum DeVries.