Brought to you by WBIW News and Network Indiana
Last updated on Monday, September 17, 2018
(UNDATED) - New Census data show that in 2017 Indiana continued to make incremental progress toward getting back to the trajectory in Indiana before the recession.
Indiana Institute for Working Families reports, there truly is a reason for the modest celebration of significant declines in poverty overall and, for many different groups, significant increases in educational attainment and median household incomes.
However, while the state is making progress on these measures, the state hasn't caught up with before the recession and the state hasn't recovered as well as some of our Midwestern neighbors.
Three indicators, in particular, are troubling and show where Indiana should focus its efforts moving forward: our gender pay gap has widened again this year and was the 3rd highest gap in the United States in 2017; housing insecurity among Hoosier renters remains shockingly and stubbornly high, and finally a decline in health insurance coverage should serve as a cautionary tale for the state not to restrict access any further.
Poverty:
Indiana's poverty rate decreased significantly from 14.1 percent in 2016 to 13.5 percent in 2017, just a tick above the new U.S. rate of 13.4 percent. There are now 871,247 Hoosiers in poverty, down from 906,077 in 2016. This is great news, as we should all be working toward a goal of no Hoosiers in poverty. Indiana is now just a bit over a percentage point away from regaining our 2007 rate of 12.3 percent However, we still have further to go to regain the 10.1 percent rate Indiana had back in 2000 when we were experiencing an economic peak. More progress needs to be made for Hoosier adults, whose poverty rate didn't drop significantly, and for Hoosier seniors, whose poverty rate remained flat at 7.7 percent.
Indiana's rate of Child Poverty dropped to 18.4 percent in 2017 down from 19.5 percent in 2016 - but unlike poverty overall, the Census says this decline is not statistically significant. While Indiana's drop in overall poverty in 2017 was significant, this seems to be driven by families with older children - those with kids under 5 did not see a significant change. This speaks to the needs for more support for families with young children, including broader access to childcare or pre-K as well as childcare tax credits.
The new Census data from 2017 matches the trend in Indiana's child poverty from our recent 'Status' report. Indiana's child poverty rate used to be well below the U.S. and even the Midwest as recently as 2004, but spiked higher shortly thereafter and, at 18.4 percent, is now tied with the U.S., and is 2.7 points above the Midwest and 3.1 pts below the South.
Looking at Hoosiers in poverty by race we also see some indications of improvement, but also lasting disparities. Hoosiers of color have seen the largest drops in poverty (1.6 points for African American, 3 points for Latinx, and 7.8 points for Asian Hoosiers). However, most Hoosiers of color remain more than twice as likely to be in poverty than white Hoosiers.
Economic Self-Sufficiency:
We know from our research on the Indiana Self-Sufficiency Standard that poverty-level income itself is not nearly enough for Hoosier families to afford life's basic costs, so we look at how many Hoosiers are living below 200 percent of the federal poverty guidelines as well. In 2017, Indiana's rate of low-income residents was 31.5 percent, with 2,034,305 Hoosiers now living below 200 percent of the federal poverty line. This is down from 32.4 percent, or 2,086,942 low-income Hoosiers in 2016. But the rate of nearly 1 in 3 Hoosiers unable to afford basic costs is still way too high. And despite continuing signs of improvement, the percent of low-income Hoosiers is still above the pre-recession level of 29.6 percent in 2007. Since 2009, basic costs have increased 31.9 percent for Hoosier families with children while wages have increased by only 6.3 percent.
Among these costs, housing insecurity is a particular concern, especially for the nearly 1 in 3 Hoosiers below self-sufficiency. In 2016, 46.1 percent of Hoosier renters paid more than 30 percent of household income on rent, a key measure of housing burden. And while this statistic of rental housing insecurity decreased to 45.7 percent in 2017, the Census Bureau did not deem this decrease as statistically significant. Affordable housing continues to be a fervent need expressed by our communities, as three cities in Indiana are among the highest in the country for evictions, waitlists for public housing assistance are too long, and affordable housing is out of reach for many low-wage earners. Asset development and home ownership programs could be part of the solution. Hoosiers who own their home are much less likely to be housing insecure. About 19 percent of those with a mortgage in 2017 paid 30 percent or more on housing costs, campers to 9.9 percent of those without a mortgage. Much less than renters! The changes from 2016 to 2017 were mostly static.
Household Income and Pay Gaps:
Like the U.S. overall, median household incomes increased significantly in Indiana, from $53,342 in 2016 to $54,181 in 2017. But the gap between the average Hoosier's and the median American's income also increased, from $5,478 to $6,155. And while Indiana's income increase of $753 is undoubtedly good for working families, it didn't keep pace with the increase of $902 for the average Midwest state.
Household income is another area where the new 2017 Census data matches the trends we found in our 'Status' report. Indiana's median household incomes, which were higher than Midwest average at the turn of the 21st century, now at $54,18 are $4,211 below the Midwest and just $220 above the average of Southern states. Indiana's median household income of $54,181 highest was 34th-highest among 50 U.S. states, up from 35th in 2016, and 10th-highest of 12 Midwest states, up from 11th.
Even with 2017's laudable gains, Hoosier households are still $2,052 shy of their pre-recession levels ($56,233 for 2007, adjusted for inflation to 2017 dollars). And Indiana would need 6 years at its current pace of income growth to catch up with the Midwest average - assuming the rest of the region saw no increase over that time.
Hoosiers' individual earnings also increased in 2017, but so did the gender wage gap. Indiana's median earnings increased significantly from $31,233 in 2016 to $32,069 in 2017, and are now just $321 shy of our pre-recession 2007 level of $32,390 (in 2017 dollars). However, this increase was driven by lopsided gains, and while the earnings for full-time, year-round men increased significantly by $876, the increase of $354 for women was not significant. Indiana now has the third-highest gender wage gap in the U.S. at $13,615, behind only Louisiana and Utah. This is up from 6th-highest in 2016 at $12,717, and 12th-highest in 2015 at $11,339.
And while Hoosiers of varying racial and ethnic groups saw increases in individual earnings, the increases did not close overall income disparities. From 2016 to 2017, African American Hoosiers gained $2,098 in median earnings, Latinx Hoosiers gained $1,374 and white Hoosiers gained $1,654. Overall, the typical Hoosier 16 or over gained $1,163 for a total of $32,069 in median earnings. However, even after these gains, African American Hoosiers remained $6,367 below the state average, Latinx Hoosiers remained $6,386 behind, and white Hoosiers remained $1,409 ahead.
Health Insurance Coverage:
We were concerned to see that Indiana's rates of health insurance coverage decreased and uninsured rates increased slightly in 2017 after years of gains. The child uninsured rate increased from 5.9 percent to 6.3 percent, and the uninsured rate for the working-age population of 19-63 increased from 12.3 percent to 12.8 percent. This is a warning sign that perhaps now is not the time to make big changes to the way Indiana covers the health care needs of low-income Hoosiers.
With 8.2 percent of Hoosiers without health coverage in 2017, Indiana has the 24th-highest rate of uninsured in the U.S. and 5th-highest of 12 Midwest states. Indiana was also 5th in the Midwest in 2016 but 23rd-highest in the U.S. that year. At 6.3 percent, Indiana had the 11th-highest rate of children without health insurance in 2017, and 2nd-highest in the Midwest. While Indiana was also 2nd-highest in the Midwest in 2016, this is an improvement from 10th-highest in the U.S. that year.
Educational Attainment:
In 2017, Indiana saw statistically significant increases in Hoosiers with Associate Degrees, and Bachelor's degrees, and significant declines in the rate of Hoosiers who only have a high school degree or less. These are promising gains for Hoosiers looking to increase their educational attainment, and for employers who increasingly demand a higher-skilled workforce.
The safety net:
New Census data shows that fewer Hoosier households were enrolled in SNAP over the past year - down from 10.8 percent in 2016 to 9.3 percent in 2017. SNAP is designed to respond to need, so as Indiana saw earnings rise, it makes sense to see a decrease in households using nutrition assistance. However, in 2017, 8.7 percent of households who were NOT receiving SNAP were below the poverty level. This may mean Indiana is still not reaching the Hoosiers that SNAP is intended to serve.
Furthermore, Indiana saw a non-significant decline in the rate of Hoosiers in deep poverty (below 50 percent of FPL). We are calling on the General Assembly to make much-needed changes to our state's Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program so that it can better serve our most vulnerable citizens.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, in 2017 Indiana saw further incremental improvements that track the ongoing national recovery. But even these uneven gains are leaving too many vulnerable residents behind, including women, Hoosiers of color, and low-income working families. As median incomes fall further behind our Midwestern peers and Hoosier women now face the 3rd-highest gender pay gap in the nation, Indiana can't afford to keep waiting for piecemeal efforts to kick in. To truly catch up and become a leader in the Midwest and the U.S. again, Indiana needs its policymakers to take bold steps to improve wage and job quality, strengthen protections, and increase economic mobility for all Hoosier families.
Information - Indiana Institute for Working Families - http://iiwf.blogspot.com
1340 AM WBIW welcomes comments and suggestions by calling 812.277.1340 during normal business hours or by email at comments@wbiw.com
© Ad-Venture Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.