The 20 IN 20: Where Is the Best Donut Shop In Indiana?

(UNDATED) – Yeast or Cake, with filling or sprinkles. No matter your preference, Indiana has a donut shop for you. But which one is the Best of Indiana?

The Indiana Department of Tourism has built a list of 20 of the best donut shops in Indiana, and now it’s time for you to choose which one is the best in the state.

Included on the list is Magic Morning in Bedford, Rainbow Bakery in Bloomington and H&H Bakery in Salem.

Voting is now open for Visit Indiana’s 2020 Best of Indiana people’s choice campaign.

Magic Morning Bakery, Best Donut Shop
Photo by @gavindaniel on Instagram

Magic Morning Bakery, Bedford

It’s said that no one has ever had a bad morning after grabbing a donut at Magic Morning Bakery. While we can’t guarantee that type of result, its freshly baked donuts and pastries will definitely put a smile on your face! Donuts, along with brownies and cookies, are baked in house daily.

Cast your vote for Magic Morning Bakery as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Rainbow Bakery, Best Donut Shop

Rainbow Bakery, Bloomington

Rainbow Bakery is Bloomington’s only all-vegan bakery, specializing in allergen-friendly and plant-based treats. Don’t let that fool you because its donuts are still amazingly sweet and flavorful! A modern folksy charm can be felt as soon as you step in, which may make you never want to leave. Rainbow Bakery even sells gluten-free items that are made at a separate workstation.

Cast your vote for Rainbow Bakery as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

H&R Bakery, Salem

H&R Bakery now has an awesome new building on the square in Salem. Donuts continue to be its signature product, but H&R Bakery is known for adding new and exciting treats. Be careful, as the donuts holes can be seriously addicting. While in Salem, plan a visit to the  John Hay Center.

Cast your vote for H&R Bakery as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Munster Donut, Donut Shop in Indiana
Photo by @dessert.oasis on Instagram

Titus Bakery, Lebanon

Titus Bakery is a third-generation, family-owned business with a top-notch reputation of making amazing donuts. Beyond its award-winning donuts and pastries, Titus has expanded its selection treats to include homemade pies and cakes. Westfield is home to the second Titus Bakery location.

Cast your vote for Titus Bakery as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Long's Bakery
Photo by @explorebel_ on Instagram

Long’s Bakery, Indianapolis

Long’s is an Indianapolis staple, baking up fresh donuts for over 60 years! Customers far and wide really come to Long’s Bakery for its world-renowned yeast donuts. This classic institution serves up a variety of treats beyond just donuts, including danishes, fritters, and cakes. The best time to arrive is about 7:30 am as the line won’t be too bad. Don’t worry though, as social distancing guidelines are strictly followed. Please keep in mind that Long’s Bakery only accepts cash.

Cast your vote for Long’s Bakery as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Donut Bank, Evansville

This is one bank that’s actually open on Sunday! Donut Bank is widely known in Evansville, with 9 locations throughout the tri-state area. Some of the top donut selections include the Cherry Bismark, Bavarian Bismarck, Coconut Long John, and Vanilla Cake. Its coffee and espresso drinks are known to be yummy also!

Cast your vote for Donut Bank as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Mary Lou Donuts, Donut Shops
Photo by @kandbshepherd on Instagram

Mary Lou Donuts, Lafayette

Lafayette is an awesome place to visit in the fall, and Mary Lou Donuts is part of the reason why. Not only does this donut shop feature a cheery dining experience, but it also has a special donut truck that can be found around town on special occasions! Mary Lou Donuts has all the favorites, from topped donuts (including sprinkles and nuts!) to yummy fruit-filled favorites. Check Mary Lou’s donut truck schedule here. 

Cast your vote for Mary Lou Donuts as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Toms Donuts, Best Donut Shop
Photo by @kelliloraine on Instagram

Tom’s Donuts, Angola

Tom’s Donuts loves to push the boundaries, so you may find new and exciting flavors on your visit! We recommend the Summer Raspberry Jelly Ball. Luckily, Angola is home to two Tom’s Donuts locations. The original can be found on N Wayne St. while the newer bakery is nestled along Lake James. Is it really lake life if there aren’t donuts involved?

Cast your vote for Tom’s Donuts as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Concannons Bakery, Best Donut Shop

Concannon’s Bakery, Muncie

Concannon’s Bakery has become famous for its delicious donuts! Opened in 1959, Concannon’s Bakery quickly grew and needed a new facility by 1978. Due to the immense popularity of its homemade donuts, Concannon’s has had to expand four times since then. Its expanded bakery cafe now features new treats like fine chocolates, coated pretzels, and gourmet popcorn.

Cast your vote for Concannon’s Bakery as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Rise’n Roll, Middlebury

A young Amish couple began Rise’n Roll in 2001 by selling baked goods from their front porch. The first storefront location opened in 2004 without using any electricity or refrigeration, meaning that everything was prepped by hand. New owners bought the company in 2009, expanding the bakery to now include 13 different locations throughout Indiana. Rise’n Roll still does things ‘the old fashioned way,’ with its signature breakfast item being the Cinnamon Caramel Donut. You must also check out the Peanut Butter Filled Donut that’s made with Amish made peanut butter!

Cast your vote for Rise’n Roll as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Heyerly's Bakery, Best Donut Shop
Photo by @nikoleclarke on Instagram

Heyerly’s Bakery, Ossian

A drive down Jefferson Street in Ossian leads you to the unassuming Heyerly’s Bakery. While it may not seem like much at first, upon entry, you’ll be greeted with a fresh aroma that might be strong enough to make your stomach growl. New owners have done wonders with this almost 100-year-old bakery, and it’s no secret why locals and tourists alike keep coming back for more.

Cast your vote for Heyerly’s Bakery as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Munster Donut, Donut Shop in Indiana
Photo by @dessert.oasis on Instagram

Munster Donut, Munster

It doesn’t get much better than a donut run on a Saturday morning to Munster Donut. Sweet and tasty is the best way to describe its Chocolate Bavarian and Chocolate Angel Cream donuts.  Due to COVID-19 restrictions, Munster Donut is only offering curbside pick up through phone orders at this time.

Cast your vote for Munster Donut as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Schmidt Bakery, Cherry Thing-A-Lings
Schmidt Bakery sold 160,716 Cherry Thing-A-Lings in February 2020!

Schmidt Bakery, Batesville

Schmidt Bakery opened in 1963, initially selling both pizza and donuts. Now a full line bakery that no longer offers pizza, its donuts still steal the show. During select happy hour days, its delicious donuts are only 50 cents!  Schmidt Bakery also whips up Cherry Thing-a-Lings once a year in February as a treat to its guests.

Cast your vote for Schmidt Bakery as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Wheel House Donuts, Best Donut Shop

Wheel House Donuts, Rockville

There’s more than Covered Bridges in Parke County.  Wheel House Donuts is the brain-child of two Canadian natives who love donuts and wanted to open a unique shop. Bask in the experience by creating your own custom donut. First, pick between chocolate, caramel, maple, vanilla, or strawberry icing. Next, add a topping! Kids might choose Fruity Pebbles or Cinnamon Toast Crunch while adults might decide upon Oreo or Reese’s Cups. Wheel House Donuts also has great coffee, crunchy salads, and tasty sandwiches.

Cast your vote for Wheel House Donuts as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Quack Daddy Donuts, Best Donut Shop
Photo by @wagonpilotdad on Instagram

Quack Daddy Donuts, Pendleton

In the revived downtown of Pendleton sits one peculiar, yet oh-so-fantastic donut shop named Quack Daddy Donuts. With over 100 total combinations, Quack Daddy Donuts, will not disappoint fans of the fried confectionary. Quack Daddy, just like Wheel House above, allows visitors to customize each order. When entering Quack Daddy Donuts, patrons take a card with a grid and design their donut. The seventeen topping options include options like bacon, coconut, M&M’s, and peanut butter drizzle.

Cast your vote for Quack Daddy Donuts as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Jacks Donuts, Best Donut Shop

Jack’s Donuts, New Castle

Jack’s Donuts is one of the most iconic donut brands in Indiana! Jack and Ada Marcum opened the first Jack’s Donuts in 1961 after they bought a New Castle shop. Three generations later, Lee Marcum decided to franchise, which means there are now 25 Jack’s Donuts throughout Indiana. However, nothing can beat the nostalgia of the original. From a classic cake donut to a bavarian cream-filled donut, the flavor can’t be understated. Carry-out, drive-thru and delivery are available at most Jack’s Donuts locations for visitors worried about social distancing.

Cast your vote for Jack’s Donuts as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Square Donuts, Best Donut Shop
Photo by @tmanaolo21 on Instagram

Square Donuts, Terre Haute

Terre Haute can’t be experienced without a morning visit to Square Donuts. Just like its name indicates, the donuts are uniquely square and surprisingly fluffy. College students, locals, and visitors all keep coming back to Square Donuts, and we think you will too after your first visit in 2020.

Cast your vote for Square Donuts as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Taylors Bakery, Best Donut Shop

Taylor’s Bakery, Indianapolis

Established in 1913, Taylor’s Bakery is celebrating its 108th year of operation. Drew and Matt Allen, owners of this family-operated bakery, specialize in donuts, cookies, pies, and specialty cakes. Donut enthusiasts will find a wide selection of both cake and yeast donuts at Taylor’s. See all of its products here.

Cast your vote for Taylor’s Bakery as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Adrienne and Co. Donuts and Desserts, Floyds Knobs

Adrienne and Co. started almost 50 years ago in New York when Myra started baking cakes for hard-working New-Yorkers. Her daughter, Adrienne, trained for years to follow in her mother’s footsteps and eventually opened up Adrienne and Co. in Jeffersonville. There are now four locations, with all of its donuts produced at Adrienne and Co. Donuts and Desserts in Floyds Knobs. Some of the delicacies include Glaze Rings, Cinnamon Tiger Tails, Red Velvet Cake Donuts, and Maple Bacon Fritters.

Cast your vote for Adrienne and Co. as Indiana’s Best Donut Shop!

Fingerhut Bakery, Best Donut Shop

Fingerhut Bakery, North Judson

Brothers Doug and Greg Fingerhut are seventh-generation bakers with their family tradition dating back to the 1700s in Bohemia. The brothers still whip up mouthwatering goods in the form of donuts, cookies, and specialty cakes. Fingerhut’s version of the Pączki, a filled donut that originated in Poland, is one of the best you will ever eat.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email